Total loss rules by state
Massachusetts: what a total loss settlement has to include
If your car was totaled in Massachusetts and the offer looks low, these are the rules the valuation is measured against.
Sales tax and fees
Sales tax could not be confirmed from the rule's text.
211 CMR 133.05
Title and registration fees are not required by a state rule, so they depend on your policy.
211 CMR 133.05
The state-level rate on a vehicle purchase is 6.25%, before any county or city tax. A valuation that applies a lower rate than that is worth a question.
Comparable vehicles
- The insurer must consider four factors: retail book value, the price paid, prior damage, and the cost of an available like vehicle. The rule sets no numeric criteria.
Most state rules let an insurer value a vehicle in more than one way. The criteria above belong to the comparable-vehicles method; a valuation produced by a computerized database is often judged under a separate provision. A comparable outside these limits is a reason to ask, not proof of a violation.
Also worth knowing
- The regulation is silent on sales tax and fees.
Source: 211 CMR 133.05. Reviewed November 2026. General information, not legal advice; the rule’s own text is the authority and may have changed.
Check your own report
Upload the valuation report your insurer sent and see what a recount finds, including these Massachusetts rules. Free, about a minute.
Check my report