By insurance company
Progressive total loss offer too low? Start with the valuation report.
The offer comes from a report Progressive buys from a valuation company. The report is where the number can be checked.
The report behind the offer
Progressive total loss valuations usually arrive as a Mitchell “Vehicle Valuation Report”. Court opinions about Progressive total losses describe Mitchell WorkCenter Total Loss reports. Insurers change vendors and use different ones in different states, so look at the name printed on the first page of yours.
If you only received a dollar figure, ask your adjuster for the complete valuation report with every comparable vehicle and adjustment. How to ask for it.
What to look for in a Mitchell report
- A “Projected Sold Adjustment” on each comparable: a deduction that assumes the car would sell below its advertised price.
- Comparables with no sold price, only an asking price reduced by that adjustment.
- Condition adjustments on the loss vehicle.
These are features of the report format, not accusations against Progressive. Courts have allowed several of these methods. They matter because each one moves your number and each can be asked about in writing.
Then check the basics
Whatever the format: does each comparable’s price plus its adjustments equal the adjusted value shown? Is the trim on the report your trim? Are your options listed? Is the mileage right? Does the total include the sales tax and fees your state requires?
Mitchell reports are next
Our reader handles CCC ONE reports today. If your Progressive valuation is a CCC ONE report, it will work; a Mitchell report will not yet.
Try my report anyway